Recommended Posts

Hi folks, I've often mentioned on this forum that I plan to switch to P3Dv4 - and I'm getting serious now. Since my knowledge about PC hardware is a bit limited, especially if it comes to gaming PCs, it would be fantastic if you experts and experienced P3Dv4 users could tell what you can recommend in terms of a good P3Dv4 hardware configuration.

 

From what I gathered from this forum and other websites so far is:

 

1) CPU: 6-core is recommended, and with an i7, there can nothing go wrong

2) Graphic card: Should have at least 8GB of memory, GTX1070 is a very decent workhorse - but how about a GTX1080?

3) 16GB DDR4 is a minimum, better choose 32GB if add-ons become more demanding in the next few years

4) A SSD is absolutely necessary to run P3Dv4, particularly the M.2 SSDs are recommended

5) In the end, it's not all about hardware, but the more important thing are the correct P3Dv4 settings

 

Have I forgotten something important? Since a new computer is of course quite an investment (but I have no alternative, since my current notebook sure wouldn't be able to cope with the demands of P3Dv4 especially for the GPU), I would prefer to make an investment for the future, so I tend to rather choose the newer and more powerful components. Unless that means to spend 3,000 euros or more, of course. ;)

 

What are your thoughts?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It sounds like you have already done some research on this, because your thoughts are pretty much on.

 

I will post the primary specs of the machine I built, and then some insight into why I chose each component:

i7 8700K (overclocked to 4.8 or so)

ASUS Maximus X Hero Wifi   (can't go wrong with ASUS or the Gigabyte Aorus series of boards)

Corsair h100i water cooler (I should have gone with the h115i Pro, quieter fans, and would allow a little more o/c)

eVGA 1080ti SC2 (also water cooled)

32 GB 3200 mhz memory

1 250 GB Samsung M.2 SSD, and 1 500 GB Samsung M.2 SSD

 

So as to the cpu, I would recommend the 8700K -- Hyperthreading ON - a decent watercooler, and with a comparable gfx card, your sim will be fine at Heathrow with AI and heavy weather, with quite good settings in P3D.

As to the vidcard, the 1080ti's are undoubtedly going to drop in price now that the RTX2080 cards are coming out.  9 months ago, I chose to future-proof somewhat, by buying a 1080ti, a card with 11GB of vidmem (we may not need this overhead now, but we might later...), and a waterblock installed from the factory (video cards run hot, and I wanted a potentially long life out of mine).  I planned to skip nVidia's next gen cards (what are now the 2080 series), unless they were must-have good (and I think I made the right choice, based on what we've seen so far of the 2080's).  I do not know your planned monitor setup, but a pair of 2080's in SLI with a 4K setup look to be the primary benefit of that card at this point in time.  However, as nVidia releases more mature driver packages for this card, its benefit could go higher for single card ops.

As to the main memory, I chose 32 GB not because our sim uses that now, but because it might at some point.  16 would work fine, too, but I also do some image work and sometimes that pushes the system memory.

As to the storage, in my opinion any decent SSD is fine.  I consider a mechanical HD to be only something I would use for mass storage/backup, at this point in time.  I am not sure my purchase of M.2 SSD's was really worth it, in terms of improving load times.  I do not know that having a boot SSD and a sim SSD really makes much difference anymore.  I did that anyway, just in case separating the OS I/O from the sim I/O still mattered.   Most importantly, however, if you plan on lot of add-ons, 500 GB will get cramped.  Mine is down to about 180 GB free, and I haven't installed any photoscenery.  If Aerosoft would quit making such good stuff, I wouldn't have this problem...

 

 

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Mace_RB Thank you very much for your recommendations and your great explanations, Rhett! Sorry for all the following questions, but this is really interesting. I numbered them, so it might be easier for you to respond to them. ;-)

 

1) I got the recommendation in the meantime, to watch for Intel CPUs with the addition "K" because it offers more reserves for overclocking. Can you confirm that, too?

 

2) The recommendation also was that a water cooler is not really needed since current fans do a sufficient job and the noise is not really a problem. So I suppose that is rather a matter of taste, and how much one gets bothered by the noise of the fans, right? Or does a water cooler really prolong the life of the hardware components?

 

3) I am also tending strongly towards investing into a 1080. What is the difference between a 1080 and a 1080ti, by the way, especially when it comes to running P3D with it? Does the ti offer more vidmem (11GB as opposed to 8GB which seems to be the standard memory for the "simple" 1080)?

 

4) In terms of monitor setup, I don't plan for two monitors, due to a lack of space on my desk and also because I'm rather a "after-work flyer" who is happy if he can see anything at all on his monitor. ;) That's also why I'm not even sure whether I should buy a 4K monitor. But I could regret that, if texture quality becomes better and better in the future, right? ;-)

 

5) 32 GB of main memory are still a bit hard to find in ready-made gaming PCs that I find on the internet and if you don't want to go far beyond the 2,000 EUR threshold. So I might go for 16 GB first and maybe a PC that makes it easy to upgrade it to 32 GB later (if that is possible).

 

6) In terms of SSD memory: Yes, 500 GB could certainly become an issue after a while, and most ready-made PCs offer even only 250 GB. I am also an avid shopper of add-ons, so this problem is not a trivial one. Can one also put add-ons on the HDD, or will that confuse P3D if it has to load some add-ons from the SSD, and some from the HDD? Is it better to put all add-ons either on the SSD or the HDD?

 

Thank you again for your support!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To at least answer your question 4, 5 and 6:

4) 4k monitor: I also have only an old 4:3 Monior with a 1600x1200 resolution and I'm happy with it. But all colleagues in the dev and deputy team having a (curved) 4k monitor never wanted to go back ;)

5) when you start with 16GB: usually a mainboard got 4 slots for RAM modules. so check that tey are not all covered with 4GB modules (this makes it sometimes cheaper) sufficient are 2 modules, each with 8GB, so you can easily add another 2x8GB; one 16GB module is the perfect solution but more expensive

6) P3D want be confused, when you put P3D itself on a SSD and your addons on another HDD. But loading time of the sim might significantly slow down when a HDD is involved. So if possible I would go for a 1TB SSD. Especially since some addon (like Orbx) can not be installed outside P3D.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As far as I know, only the 'K' processors are overclockable. The non 'K' processors are not. And since the sim benefits a lot of a higher clockspeed, you'd be foolish to not choose a 'K' as long as you have the funds for a decent CPU cooler.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks, @mopperle, for your answers! I will try to find out whether those ready-made PCs have all 4 RAM slats covered or not. And maybe, depending on what is left of my budget, I will stick to a non-4K monitor, too. ;-) 1TB SSDs are usually not part of the ready-made PCs I saw so far, but I will check whether it is possible to change that inside the package and upgrade to a larger SSD.

Thank you also, @Roelio! What do you recommend as CPU cooler? Is a water cooler necessary in your opinion or will a fan cooler do as well?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I always got a bad feeling when it comes to ready-made PCs, usually they're not that good. Occasionally there's a good one, but mostly there's always something about them that's not completely as you desire.

 

The best PCs are custom-made. They're tailored to your wishes, exactly as you want them to be. And it doesn't have to be more expensive than a ready-made PC, in fact it's mostly cheaper. The better computer shops can have a PC custom built for you. If they can't, don't buy there! It tells something about the level of service in the shop. Alternatively, you can buy a pile of parts and build it yourself. It's not extremely difficult.

 

I can tell you a story from a guy who also bought a ready-made PC a few years ago. Everything worked great until he decided he needed a better video card. He took the old video card out and put the new one in, and the computer didn't boot. What turned out to be the problem? The producer of the PC had calculated that with it's original hardware the PC would never consume more than 200 watt, so they put a 200 watt PSU in it. However the new video card required a bit more, so he also had to replace the PSU in order to get the new video card to work.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, PatrickZ said:

I always got a bad feeling when it comes to ready-made PCs, usually they're not that good. Occasionally there's a good one, but mostly there's always something about them that's not completely as you desire.

 

The best PCs are custom-made. They're tailored to your wishes, exactly as you want them to be. And it doesn't have to be more expensive than a ready-made PC, in fact it's mostly cheaper. The better computer shops can have a PC custom built for you. If they can't, don't buy there! It tells something about the level of service in the shop. Alternatively, you can buy a pile of parts and build it yourself. It's not extremely difficult.

 

I can tell you a story from a guy who also bought a ready-made PC a few years ago. Everything worked great until he decided he needed a better video card. He took the old video card out and put the new one in, and the computer didn't boot. What turned out to be the problem? The producer of the PC had calculated that with it's original hardware the PC would never consume more than 200 watt, so they put a 200 watt PSU in it. However the new video card required a bit more, so he also had to replace the PSU in order to get the new video card to work.

 

Sadly, this is a very true and realistic view on ready made Desktop PCs, and depending on who the builder is upgrading them can certainly cause issues. 

 

Now, I was once (I'm retired) a computer engineer, and short of my old Tandy and Apple computer days (when I was troublesghooting and fixing mainframe computers) I have always built my own.  With a little research, it's actually easy to do.  My son is now in his 30's, but back when he was 15 and there was barely an Internet and no Youtube Videos to help you out, he built his own computer without any input or help from me.  So it's not really difficult and it will save you money!

 

 

  • Upvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, FWAviation said:

@Mace_RB Thank you very much for your recommendations and your great explanations, Rhett! Sorry for all the following questions, but this is really interesting. I numbered them, so it might be easier for you to respond to them. ;-)

 

1) I got the recommendation in the meantime, to watch for Intel CPUs with the addition "K" because it offers more reserves for overclocking. Can you confirm that, too?

 

2) The recommendation also was that a water cooler is not really needed since current fans do a sufficient job and the noise is not really a problem. So I suppose that is rather a matter of taste, and how much one gets bothered by the noise of the fans, right? Or does a water cooler really prolong the life of the hardware components?

 

3) I am also tending strongly towards investing into a 1080. What is the difference between a 1080 and a 1080ti, by the way, especially when it comes to running P3D with it? Does the ti offer more vidmem (11GB as opposed to 8GB which seems to be the standard memory for the "simple" 1080)?

 

4) In terms of monitor setup, I don't plan for two monitors, due to a lack of space on my desk and also because I'm rather a "after-work flyer" who is happy if he can see anything at all on his monitor. ;) That's also why I'm not even sure whether I should buy a 4K monitor. But I could regret that, if texture quality becomes better and better in the future, right? ;-)

 

5) 32 GB of main memory are still a bit hard to find in ready-made gaming PCs that I find on the internet and if you don't want to go far beyond the 2,000 EUR threshold. So I might go for 16 GB first and maybe a PC that makes it easy to upgrade it to 32 GB later (if that is possible).

 

6) In terms of SSD memory: Yes, 500 GB could certainly become an issue after a while, and most ready-made PCs offer even only 250 GB. I am also an avid shopper of add-ons, so this problem is not a trivial one. Can one also put add-ons on the HDD, or will that confuse P3D if it has to load some add-ons from the SSD, and some from the HDD? Is it better to put all add-ons either on the SSD or the HDD?

 

Thank you again for your support!

 

I think everyone has already given good answers to your questions.

 

1.  K cpus Yes definitely go for a "K" cpu -- you will want to overclock, even just a little mild overclock helps immensely in the sim, and it's simple and easy to do with a good motherboard.  My Asus Maximus X Hero motherboard, for example, has factory-pre-sets for mild overclocking.   That motherboard may be past your budget, and not needed for your build, BUT you can find a motherboard by ASRock that will be inexpensive but still allow for some overclocking.

2.  Watercool vs. air In many cases the fans on a watercooler are the same sound-volume as an air fan cooler would be, so yes, I concur with whoever told you that.  I would say if you're just doing a mild overclock, an air cooler will do perfectly fine.  You will want a water cooler if you want to push it to around 5.0 ghz, but that's a pretty solid overclock and maybe beyond what you're looking to do.

3. 1080 vs 1080ti   That's not something I have researched.  I /think/ the non-ti 1080's have less memory, but I'm not sure about that -- hopefully someone else has firsthand knowledge.  I do not know if the non-ti's have slower clocks or less features, either.  1080Ti's should drop in price as the RTX2080 cards are out now.

4. monitor -- I don't run a 4K screen, either, but I think moving forward it will be the way to go.   Like me, you may be quite happy with a non-4K monitor.   I know Mathijs and a lot of the Aerosoft folks are using 4K's now and curved etc. and it's something to look into, for sure. 

5. memory -- 16 GB is fine.  I agree with Otto, if you buy 2x8gb modules, you can always add 2 more later to go to 32 GB if your motherboard has 4 ram slots.  I would consider ram with the lowest CAS latency you can find, from a quality vendor like G.Skill, Corsair, Crucial, etc.

6. disk -- I agree with the others I would go for a 1 TB SSD.  Maybe buy a big hard drive for backup / archive purposes.

 

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Another problem with "cookie-cutter" PC's is that the manufacturer will use the slowest / cheapest/ least reliable components they can.   Like that 200 watt power supply PatrickZ mentioned.   If you get a 1080 card you will want at least a 600 watt PSU, preferably 800 watt if you plan to overclock.  Price difference isn't that much.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks, @Mace_RB, Dave and Patrick (sadly, I can't link your two profiles here - is that linking function limited to one profile only?) for your advice! The German online store that was recommended to me (Mifcom) has a good reputation among gamers and advertises with only using high-quality hardware. You also have many possibilities to switch the individual hardware components in their packages to components you prefer. You will have to do some individual modifications anyway, since their packages usually don't include the operating system yet. But since I want to save time and even with a YouTube tutorial, I would feel unsure, I rather not build a computer on my own. I have actually made good experiences in the past with a desktop computer that was built in a shop after I chose the components I preferred. I guess that if you don't have much understanding of how hardware components interact etc., that is the safer way to go. It might also save time and nerves.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Regarding memory. Use always a pair of modules. Not just a single one.

The CPU has a dual channel interface (the very expensive ones have quad channel), if you only use one slot, you limit the bandwidth.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mifcom and other shops where they assemble your components for a small fee are not comparable to those offering preconfigured systems, I would say going this way is safe enough. Just don't go for this single 16GB RAM module that was mentioned above, you will loose the DualChannel doing so. While this does not make a huge difference, I would not miss the increased bandwith you get with DualChannel...

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
22 hours ago, FWAviation said:

Thank you also, @Roelio! What do you recommend as CPU cooler? Is a water cooler necessary in your opinion or will a fan cooler do as well?

 

I run a Corsair H100i for a few years now and it keeps my 4770k @4.6Ghz in check. Although, this summer it was quite hot here in NL and I had to turn down the clockspeed because my CPU got too hot. But we're talking room temperatures of around 40C, so I was not surprised at all that the cooler couldn't handle it. I prefer a AIO water cooler, because of the cleaner look and easier acces to components in my PC case. But a big air cooler should cool around the same degree while doing it a bit quieter as well. It all comes down to preference and budget ;)

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Regarding AiO you should also consider this: in the unlikely event that the water pump fails, the water evaporates or something else is broken, this would usually mean you have to replace the whole thing. A basic air cooler such as the NH-U14S is technically more simple, the only moving part that can actually break is the fan, this is replaced in some minutes and much cheaper than replacing the full thing. Although I personally know some people with an AiO and none of them ever broke down, you can read from many others in the net that their AiO failed after some years. Or the pump became much louder.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's really great advice, @Roelio and @Querer - thanks! Especially your statement, Querer, falls in line with what I heard elsewhere already - it's not necessary and can even be more bothersome to have a water cooler instead of an air cooler.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Most flight simmers (using high end third party addons) overclock their processors, and doing this brings more heat.  I've been using the the Corsair coolers for many, many years without any issue whatsoever and it's meant my being able to run extremely cool - which not only is a plus for performance, but longevity of the processor as well.

 

Best wishes.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now